What is Systems Economics?

In the last few years, I have faced several socially awkward situations at social gatherings when people ask me what I do for a living. “What do you work with?” It wasn’t the first time I was faced with a lack of description of what I do. Since I graduated with a master’s degree ten years ago in socio-ecological resilience for sustainable development, with a double bachelor’s degree in peace and development studies and economics, there has never been an easy way to describe my expertise or education. I guess my three years at the Swedish Red Cross, as their sustainability coordinator, were probably among the easiest and most relatable titles. Since then, I’ve just said, “I work with sustainability.” But it doesn’t describe at all what I’m engaged in these days.

After some contemplation among “Wellbeing Economics”, “Common Good Economics”, “Beyond GDP” and so forth, I have started to describe myself as a systems economist since the word itself is self-descriptive. Further, it’s easy to say in both Swedish and English, while Wellbeing Economics becomes long and complicated in Swedish (Ekonomi för välbefinnande; the Danish Trivselsøkonomi is, in that case, better).

Nor do I think “heterodox economist” is the correct title, since heterodox economics is an umbrella term for approaches that challenge mainstream economics and includes ecological, feminist, institutional, post-Keynesian and Marxian economics. Since the term is based on challenging the mainstream and includes conflicting ideas, theories and assumptions, it can sometimes be even harder to understand one’s position than if one simply said “economist”. It can also be assumed to be associated with “left-wing” economics.

Despite systems economics being the best choice, people still don’t know what it means or what systems economics entails. As far as I know, there is no formal definition (even though the term is used in mainstream economics to mean something else), and I have not seen it used as a title or profession by other people. The description and clarification below are, as such, my own understanding of it, and I hope they help and inspire you to broaden your understanding of economics and the role it plays in our lives.

 

How systems economics is framed by mainstream economics

If you research economic systems online, you will come across a description of four major systems. The idea behind these four systems is that economists seek to understand the structure in which goods and services are produced, distributed and consumed within a society. These systems dictate not only what is produced but also how it is produced and who benefits from it. The four main types are free market economies (however, the market is not truly free, not even the so-called “free market” we have now), command (or planned, which many economists associate with communism) economies, mixed economies and, sometimes, traditional economies. In a free market economy, the government has limited intervention, and consumers and businesses make economic decisions based on competition and demand. Command economies have centralised planning, where the government makes all economic decisions on what is produced and distributed based on needs or wants. Mixed economies combine elements of both systems, balancing government regulation with free market principles with different aims. Traditional economies are grounded in historical practices.

To broaden the mainstream definition of systems economics, one can look at the journal Economic Systems, which publishes research on how institutions, governance structures and macro-financial policies shape economic outcomes across countries and regions. The articles published focus on structural change, integration, development, transition or institutional reform, typically looking at how economic policies and institutional arrangements jointly influence growth, stability, inequality, innovation and financial development. In other words, institutions, governance, politics (monetary and fiscal), globalisation, inequality, innovation and human capital are also included. However, I doubt that its theoretical scope is broader than that of traditional mainstream economics, since the journal emphasises that theoretical papers are not normally included, and it emphasises quantitative analysis founded on econometrics and so on as a method (not that heterodox economics can’t include these methods).

This explanation by mainstream economics is probably one of the reasons why many mainstream economists get confused and critical when heterodox economists talk about systems economics. I believe they assume we are suggesting a more command or state-controlled economy, based on the traditional four alternatives of economic systems, which is not at all what is being discussed or suggested.

 

What I mean WHEN I say: Systems Economics

I use the term to describe economics as mainstream economics would define it, but systems economics deals with economics in a larger context. Inspired by Donella Meadows, I understand a system as a set of interconnected elements that are organized coherently to achieve something: it consists of elements, the interconnections between them, and a function or purpose. What matters most is often not the individual parts but how they are connected and what the system is set up to do. Seen this way, the economy is not a separate machine but one system among many, shaped by the relationships and feedback loops it shares with the others.

It does include traditional macro- and microeconomics and its cousins: economic history, labour economics, ecological economics, feminist economics, colonial economics and so on. But it also includes how the economic system is dependent on, embedded in and interacts with other systems, such as cultural, social and ecological systems.

 

Which Principles of Systems Economics Do I Look Into?

  • The economy is dependent on the natural world, and it has its limits and is finite

  • The economy needs materials and energy for its activities, and these need to be visible

  • Economics is a social science, and mathematics should be applied with a clarifying theoretical lens and clear assumptions

  • The purpose, goal and long-term outcome of the system matter, and they are political

  • What is not easy to measure still matters (and can even be the most essential resource), and it needs to be considered and accounted for

 

In what ways does Systems Economics separate itself from other alternative Models?

I see systems economics as an umbrella term. In other words, economic models such as Doughnut Economics, Wellbeing Economics, Regenerative Economics, Common Good Economics and so on are all part of systems economics. This doesn’t mean that their models will necessarily result in systems change, but they do question the economic system and aim at redefining the purpose and function of economic systems.

 

Is SYSTEMS Economics left-wing economics?

No, not at all. Systems economics aims to understand the system in itself and the fundamental theories, ideologies and history it is based on. Even though models and the efforts of systems economics can be centred around human wellbeing, systems economics doesn’t explicitly prefer another established ideology or theory beyond today’s mainstream neoliberal capitalist system, such as Keynesianism or communism. It is a common mistake to confuse criticism of today’s economic system and its dependence on growth with a preference for an anti-market, large-state economy. I believe this has to do with the Cold War era, when the competition for world dominance was between the USA and the Soviet Union and their respective political and economic models. The victory of the USA and the West was seen as the victory of capitalism and the free market, which have been associated with individual freedom and liberation, while the Soviet Union was associated with the lack of such freedoms (at least afterwards, from a Western perspective).

Further, many of the policy proposals that systems economists and related movements put forward are sometimes similar to those presented by more left-wing oriented political parties. These similarities relate to resource distribution, public funding for health care, wealth taxes and environmental taxes. But systems economists seem to go beyond applicable policy proposals by asking what people truly want and what facilitates human wellbeing in the long run, and by delivering those needs and wants within a framework rooted in the planetary boundaries and based on principles such as human rights and democracy. Beyond that, the theory, values, systems designs and models can be vastly different.

Because the traditional typology has only one axis, market versus state, criticism of the current system is easily mistaken for a preference for the state. Systems economics asks a different question (what the economy serves and what it depends on), so it doesn’t map onto that axis.

 

Are SYSTEMS Economics ANTI-GROWTH, anti-market and anti-capitalist?

I would say these three come with a weaker and weaker yes, but it will depend on who you ask. Many systems economists and people within the movement come from the climate and environmental movement. There is a large consensus and understanding (backed up by research) that the current growth model requires cheap energy and resource supply, and that the rate of decoupling (where the economy grows without using more energy and materials) is mostly absent or, in some cases, too slow or too small for countries to meet the goals of the Paris Agreement and stay within the planetary boundaries. As such, there is a common understanding that there can’t be infinite growth on a finite planet. Some might understand and communicate this and seek change as part of the degrowth movement, while others might not use the word degrowth but will mostly sympathise with its methods, if one understands it correctly (which is reduced material and energy consumption in GDP-rich countries while improving wellbeing for their citizens).

When it comes to markets, they have existed for thousands of years and are much older than capitalism itself. Capitalism and markets are often treated and talked about as if they were the same thing, which they are not. Markets can exist, and have existed, without capitalism. My understanding is that there are different approaches here to how to regulate and design markets. I’ve seen everything from people wanting to remove or change the demand-and-supply model itself (for example, instead of allowing prices to guide the market, listing demands first so that production only happens based on people’s expressed wishes or anticipated demand and not on what is available on the market, which I would say is quite related to a more command-based economy) to people wanting only to change the price mechanism by adding externalities to production costs, such as carbon taxes or environmental taxes. Other ideas relate to the actors and flows of the market, for example, increasing the number of actors or replacing them entirely, such as having companies be only non-profit rather than private and profit-based. As I see it, markets will continue, and many are rather eager to make them work better (including being more efficient and competitive) with increased localisation, decentralisation, diversity of ownership and removal of the large-scale dominant companies that shape today’s global markets.

Capitalism is a hot topic and is questioned by many. What is, however, unclear (and where I see a research gap) is whether capitalism can continue if we want to create an economy in service of all within planetary boundaries. This concerns both the methods and pathways that take us there and whether capitalism can remain the system once we have arrived. One of the dilemmas is that there is no universally agreed-upon definition. If one defines capitalism as the private ownership of capital, where investments (existing surplus) are used to invest in private ownership to gain more surplus (hence companies’ profits), a capitalist system goes hand in hand with growth, since with investment and the creation of surplus, the market (money, assets, etc.) in accumulation will grow. This means that growth follows if the profit created is reinvested, which seems to be the major drive in today’s system. This doesn’t mean that systems economists by default question private ownership; it depends on what is done with that ownership. What is being questioned is capitalism’s built-in drive for growth and, by some people, private ownership itself, depending on one’s ideological background.

 

End Note

I hope this article helps you navigate, think about and create your own understanding of systems economics. I don’t claim to know exactly what it is or to be the only representative. I am only sharing my own understanding based on several years of work in the field of heterodox economics. I believe there is a need for theoretical development and research to better define, structure and place real systems economics in the scientific field, among economic practitioners and in our institutions. I hope this is the seed of a start in that direction, since we truly need better understanding, tools and ways to structure the economy in service of people and the planet, today, tomorrow, for everyone and everywhere.